Tartine Bread


At Christmas, my sister-in-law, Katina, and her husband, Jeff, gave me a new bread book called Tartine Bread, which was written by a (locally) famous baker in their city of San Francisco.  I had only seen the cover before and not read much about it.  At the time I was just delving into a fairly new book about bread called Whole Grain Breads by Peter Reinhart.  This would be my second major bread book after his Bread Baker’s Apprentice.  I have checked out other books from the library and I have read many, many blog posts on thefreshloaf, but my main guidance and formulas have been from Reinhart since I began baking, aside from a loaf here and there, which has been these last 6 years.

Since my father recently became interested in baking, I decided it would be fun to do a lot of baking when we went to Kansas.  I also decided it would be interesting to bring the Tartine book with us – it had been getting a lot of attention on the blogs of thefreshloaf.com, and I knew there was something to the dutch oven technique after seeing what the no-knead bread could do.

I reinvigorated my sourdough starter, Ralph, a couple of days before we traveled, feeding him with freshly ground flour.  One morning I began the Basic Country Loaf in this book, intending to cook it in an enameled dutch oven my mother had.  While we were in Joplin, MO, my dad decided to buy two Lodge Combo Cookers – one for himself and one for us.  This is the style of dutch oven used in the Tartine book.  We happened to purchase them at a great price ($30/each) at a store that has now been destroyed by tornado.

The first Reinhart book introduced me to baking – in particular I learned to bake sourdough breads and to use a retarded fermentation to develop flavor.  The delayed fermentation was a focus of the book while the sourdough was mostly a side note.  The second book introduced me to techniques more suited to whole wheat breads, such as using a soaker overnight to fully hydrate the flour.  It was still difficult getting whole wheat breads that compared in look and crumb texture to the white flour breads I had been baking before.  The taste was different, but that was to be expected.  I had also read here and there on thefreshloaf.com and in one Reinhart formula about the “stretch and fold” technique as a gentler and simpler method of kneading.  I hadn’t had much success with it on Reinhart’s ciabatta formula and decided it should wait until further study.

I was also familiar with what’s known as “no-knead” bread.  This is the kind of bread that Elizabeth makes.  It is a high hydration dough that is not kneaded but left to an “autolyse” process for a long period of time.  This bread came out with a fairly consistent crumb full of holes, though the flavor and overall shape did not seem well developed.

Tartine put some of these different ideas together into what has been a very successful and consistent method.  It involves sourdough for leavening, a high hydration level, the stretch and fold method, significant autolyse, and a dutch oven baking environment (as does the no-knead).  This dutch oven, however, would be shallow (to allow scoring of the loaf) with a deep lid (to allow significant oven spring), vastly improving oven spring and appearance.  He also allows for a retarded fermentation to develop more flavor and a soaker for whole wheat, though neither is necessary for successful bread.

The purpose of the dutch oven is to retain high heat after preheating and opening the oven door and to retain moisture.  When I was first baking I would splash water onto the oven walls to create steam in the oven.  There were two problems with this: I could see the steam escaping the oven and I eventually cracked the oven glass.  I then moved to boiling soaked rags and putting them in a loaf pan in the bottom of the oven.  These released steam as long as they were in the oven, but they didn’t release enough, and what was released into the oven quickly escaped out of the vents.  The dutch oven does not need additional steam because it traps all of the moisture and steam released from the dough itself and keeps the exterior of the bread moist.  Why do you need steam?  In order to prevent the exterior of the loaf from immediately hardening and to instead allow the entire loaf to expand with what is called “oven spring” – this can be the difference between a dense and a light loaf.

When we came home from Joplin, I took the retarded loaves out of the refrigerator and preheated the dutch oven.  Reinhart usually says to wait two hours for refrigerated dough to warm up, but the Tartine book said to only wait about 20 minutes.  I then dusted what would be the bottom of the loaf with some rice flour so it would not stick during cooking.

I then made my approach to place the loaf into the preheated skillet / dutch oven.


Scoring (next to impossible in a traditional dutch oven):

Putting the bread in the oven and placing the lid on top.

The results:

1st attempt:


2nd attempt:

3rd attempt:

4th attempt:

This was a 70% whole wheat bread.  I made a few mistakes with this one, the most obvious of which is partly dropping the lid on the top of one of the loaves before it was cooked!

(the edge nearly always looks nicer than the middle!)


The process is significantly less labor-intensive.  The attentiveness required is little more than the Reinhart sourdough was.  The results are much more consistent.  As compared with the “no-knead”, the stretches and folds help the bread build up more structure so that the final shape and crumb holes are both more impressive.  The sourdough leaven provides both better flavor and longer keeping qualities.  The dutch oven technique produces consistent and great oven spring, as well as great color and crust thickness.

I’m not yet completely satisfied with the whole wheat.  It seems better than the no-knead variety we’ve made before.  Hopefully without the same mistakes it will spring more and there will be more visible signs of strong gluten development.  As we went further into the loaf there remained some large holes, but between the holes was significantly denser than I would have liked.

Overall, I think this is a wonderful method for the home baker.  It is not that difficult – no time kneading away at the table, not that I don’t like kneading.  This will be my go-to bread aside from experimentation here and there.  I’m particularly interested to mix Reinhart’s soaking method with this book’s stretch and fold technique, if I can.

The book is filled with a few other breads and then several food recipes in the back to be used with the breads in the book.  Today we are going to try making pizza per the book’s crust instructions, which basically means using the dough from the Basic Country Loaf without shaping into a boule or proofing.

I’ll let you know how it turns out!

Thank you, Katina and Jeff.
Thank you, Papou Sam.


P.S. This has also convinced us to embrace cast iron cookware wholeheartedly.  Helpfully, this has contributed to our kitchen beautification project.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses to “Tartine Bread”

  1. thischo Says:

    your bread looks delicious!

  2. Katina Says:

    Oh man! So glad the book is proving useful. I can’t wait to try the fruits/breads of your labor in July!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: